Hoagie Haven

Mark Husey 2 months ago

As a musician, I know that you are judged by your most recent performance, despite former days of glory. It breaks my heart yet needs to be said: the Hoagie Haven of 1991, or even of 2025, has ceased to be. On my way to Baltimore, I drove there from Port Jefferson, Long Island *in the rain* for what be a used to be a glorious pizza cheesesteak and received some mystery slop on an oversized roll that they didn't even bother to cut in half and wrap for ease of consumption. WIth the campus of Westminster Choir College closed, I can't think of a single reason to set foot in this town ever again.

G R A C E 2 months ago

Got the Chavez and liked the sauce as well as ius contents. Liked how the fried shrimp had lettuce and tomato in it A sandwich is quite large so eating a half is already a good serving size!

Tatiana Hoover 4 months ago

We visited on National Hoagie Day and the sandwich was DELICIOUS! Big, with generous stuffing and really great bread. We had the sausage hoagie but there are lots of wonderful combinations. The staff was friendly. Took our order right away and the sandwich was ready in no time. There are LOTS of to go orders, so one does have to be patient. There are a few stools for eating inside, but it’s more of a “to-go” place. I asked one of the servers if I could take a photo of his Hoagie shirt and he happily agreed :)

Towan Harrison Jr 5 months ago

This is my first time at Hoagie Haven and I gotta say I wish I lived closer to this spot. I would genuinely get this everyday. There’s so many unique sandwiches to choose from I personally had the Sanchez and a cheesesteak sandwich, there’s nothing else like it around. There is no substitute you either if you want this taste you have to come here. Highly recommend!! If this was by my job I’d get it frequently for lunch!

Chuck Mound 9 months ago

This place was recommended by many foodies as a must stop while in Princeton. The food item of choice was the cheesesteak. But before I can get to the cheesesteak, I have to share the overall sub sandwich experience. As a place that had been a staple in Princeton for 50 years, you would expect to have some type of an old school experience that would lend this place to be a destination. Parking? Forget about it, there are a few metered spots that you have to be extremely lucky to get one. Plan on driving around a while. Once you do find a spot, do not forget you wallet because that is the next obstacle..No Cash is accepted for your order that must be placed on the Kios. No greeting welcoming you to the famous Hoagir Haven. Just a sign saying No Cash Accepted and order here. Nobody to talk about what they recommended? What is popular? What you can get on your sandwich? Extras. Just a Kios that is no different than ordering from your local Wawa. I wanted my cheesestreak with ketchup and pickles, this was not part of the options. If it was, didn't have time for a long search with the line behind me. So I received a plain cheesesteak, which was good based on the solid foundation of the